unbiased

Politics20h21 outletslean right average

LeftLean leftCenterLean rightRight

Some ratings on this page are entered from the public AllSides ratings and not yet verified against the licensed feed.

New York City Council Votes to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages by 2028

What happened

The New York City Council voted 40 to 7 on Thursday to ban horse-drawn carriage rides by June 2028. The legislation, known as Romanch's Law, is named after a teenager who died this summer after being thrown from a carriage. The Transport Workers Union has threatened to challenge the ban in court, and President Trump criticized the decision.

Side by side

Left9 versions

Left outlets frame the ban through the lens of the law's namesake, emphasizing that "Romanch's Law" was "named after teen who died when he was ejected from carriage earlier this year." They describe the Council as having "moved to ban" the carriages.

Center8 versions

Center outlets provide straightforward reporting on the vote itself, noting that "drivers are livid" and that Trump "slams" or "mourns" the decision. They describe the carriages as a "tourist staple" or "Central Park tourist staple dating to the 19th century."

Right33 versions

Right outlets emphasize the longevity of the practice, repeatedly calling it a "150-year-old Central Park tradition" or "century-old horse-drawn carriage industry." Multiple outlets feature claims that the ban is "actually a scheme to benefit real estate interests" or represents "elite virtue-signaling," and describe drivers as "betrayed" and fearing "homelessness." They characterize the ban as occurring "for political reasons" and use phrases like "foolish" and "scary socialist precedent."

Bias ratings from AllSides Media Bias Ratings™. Ratings are fluid and change as outlets change. Unbiased links to the source article rather than reproducing it. A few outlets no longer publish a feed and reach us through Google News; their links are marked, and they pass through Google before reaching the outlet.

How ratings workAllSidesPrivacy
New York City Council Votes to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages by 2028 — Unbiased