Some ratings on this page are entered from the public AllSides ratings and not yet verified against the licensed feed.
Justice Kagan Says Supreme Court Rulings Have Weakened Democracy and Increased Polarization
What happened
Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan spoke at Catholic University on Tuesday, two weeks before the midterm elections, criticizing recent Supreme Court decisions. She argued that rulings on gerrymandering, campaign finance, and voting rights have weakened American democracy and increased political polarization. Kagan specifically addressed decisions that weakened the Voting Rights Act and allowed more partisan gerrymandering.
Side by side
Left outlets emphasize the conservative majority's "antidemocratic actions" and frame Kagan as warning or reminding Americans about threats to democracy. HuffPost and MS NOW use language like "undermining democracy" and "antidemocratic" prominently in their framing.
- MSJustice Kagan reminds Americans of Supreme Court majority’s antidemocratic actionsMS NOW · Left
- TDBJustice Kagan Criticizes Supreme Court Rulings on Voting and Campaign FinanceThe Daily Beast · Left
- HPJustice Kagan Warns Supreme Court Rulings Are Fueling Polarization And Undermining DemocracyHuffPost · Left
- TMAhead of Midterms, Elena Kagan Says the Supreme Court Is Undermining Voting RightsTime · Lean Left
- ABCJustice Kagan warns Supreme Court rulings fueling polarization, undermining democracyABC News · Lean Left
- APJustice Kagan warns Supreme Court rulings are fueling polarization and undermining democracyAssociated Press · Lean Left · link via Google News
- NBCJustice Elena Kagan accuses Supreme Court’s conservative majority of undermining democracyNBC News · Lean Left
Center outlets focus on Kagan's critique of specific rulings without emphasizing partisan framing. The Hill and Reuters describe her comments as criticism that rulings "heightened political polarization" or have been "destructive to democracy" without leading with the conservative-liberal divide.
- NWElena Kagan Trashes Conservative SCOTUS Justices' 'Misconceived' TheoryNewsweek · Center
- HILKagan: Supreme Court rulings have heightened political polarizationThe Hill · Center
- RTRUS high court rulings have been 'destructive to democracy,' Justice Kagan saysReuters · Center · link via Google News
Right outlets frame the story around Kagan's partisanship or internal conflict. RealClearPolitics leads with "Justice Kagan's Partisanship Problem" and accuses her of favoring Democratic gerrymandering. Fox News emphasizes she "turns on her own court" and is making a "dire warning."
- RCPJustice Kagan's Partisanship ProblemRealClearPolitics · Lean Right
- WEXElena Kagan says Supreme Court’s recent decisions have hurt democracyWashington Examiner · Lean Right
- FOXSupreme Court Justice Kagan warns some conservative rulings have been 'destructive of our democracy'Fox News Digital · Right
- FOXSupreme Court justice turns on her own court with dire warning about American democracyFox News Digital · Right
Bias ratings from AllSides Media Bias Ratings™. Ratings are fluid and change as outlets change. Unbiased links to the source article rather than reproducing it. A few outlets no longer publish a feed and reach us through Google News; their links are marked, and they pass through Google before reaching the outlet.